Senate Appropriations Chair Susan Collins (R-ME), who lost her election and will be leaving the Senate, released draft FY27 appropriations bills this week, hoping to get the long-delayed federal spending process moving and finish work before the end of the year. But the bills, developed without Democratic input or support, face an uncertain future, according to AFSA Legislative Director Jon Bernstein.
For education, the proposed Labor, Health and Human Services, Education, and Related Agencies bill largely maintains current funding levels across federal programs. Title I and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) would receive modest increases, while two programs important to educators, Title II-A and Title IV-A, would remain level funded.
The Senate Republican proposal also addresses several Department of Education policies. It does not prohibit interagency agreements, but instead requests briefings on them. The accompanying report also urges the Department to follow statutory program priorities and requirements when developing and issuing notices inviting applications, providing program guidance, and administering multi-year grants. In addition, it continues a previous requirement that education funds be distributed in a timely manner.
Democrats have made clear they are not on board with the proposals. Incoming Senate Appropriations Chair Patty Murray (D-WA) criticized the bills following their release, arguing that Republicans are putting too much emphasis on defense spending while doing too little to address the needs of American families.
"Families want relief from sky-high prices and meaningful action to take on this administration’s corruption; the bills released today fail to do either," Murray said in her November 16 statement. She added that Democrats cannot support a funding agreement that provides a major increase for defense contractors while offering far less for other federal priorities.
Murray also took aim specifically at the Labor-HHS-Education bill, saying it fails to adequately support students and families or rein in the administration's actions at the Department of Education.
"While Senate Republicans propose spending hundreds of billions of dollars more to meet President Trump’s outlandish request for the war budget, this bill does remarkably little to help struggling families," Murray said. She also criticized the proposal for failing to prevent the dismantling of the Department of Education or the politicization of federal grants. Murray called for greater investments in education, public health, child care, and other programs that help families meet everyday expenses.
The lack of Democratic involvement in developing the bills, combined with the approaching change in congressional control in January, makes their prospects for passage uncertain. Democrats are unlikely to simply accept the Republican proposals, leaving open the question of whether any of the bills can advance through the Senate Appropriations Committee, much less pass the full Senate.
That leaves Congress facing a familiar alternative: another short-term continuing resolution (CR). With the current CR set to expire December 11, lawmakers may need to approve another temporary funding measure to keep the government operating into at least January. That would leave the FY27 spending process for the incoming Congress to take up.
